The supposed issues with e-voting
I just love the hullabaloo around e-voting. Take this:
Part of the problem arises from the complexity of e-voting systems. The code that makes up these systems is so large that there's no efficient way for election officials to ensure that it's free of malware or to completely debug it, according to testimony Johns Hopkins University professor Avi Rubin gave before the U.S. Election Assistance Commission this spring
Complexity? Seriously, how complex should a system like this be? It's an automated multiple choice list. If the people writing such systems made them complex, then find better developers. Seriously, this doesn't even begin to be a complex domain problem. As to security, that's mostly an issue of separating the systems from public (net) access, and verifying that only authorized staff has back end access. In other words, problems we know how to solve. Then there's this:
If you thought pregnant chads in the 2000 election were bad, wait until you see what a determined hacker could do to the democratic process this fall. That is, of course, if we're lucky enough to detect the attack.
What, this columnist has never heard of ballot box stuffing? I'll refer her back to the history of Tammany Hall in New York - this sort of system is no more (but also no less) secure than any other system out there.


Comments
e-voting
[brett hallett] July 26, 2004 7:58:57.608
I was listening to the radio last Saturday ( Radio National (Australia) ) to a program called "the Buzz" where they were discussion this very topic!
Appears that the Australain Capital Territory has sucessfully had a full blown election using e-voting, e-voting was use mainly because of the very complex voting system ( Hare-Clark) - complex to collate results , not complex to actually vote.
Also Brazil has just recently used e-voting for a country wide election. Even took the gear into the real Amazon jungle and ran it using a row of 12 volt car batteries!
As james says - "some people are just trying to make it too difficult!", other people just get on with it and try it out.
The Buzz might be available on line via the Australain Broadcasting System (ABC) web site