Speaking of Math...
Lee Gomes of the WSJ reports on the TopCoder contest, and comes to this conclusion:
The results have been carefully tabulated by a computer and, thus, are beyond dispute: Of the 48 best computer programmers in the world, only four of them are Americans. But what that bit of data says about the state of the U.S. education system is open to debate.
Hmm. So Lee, if I set up an online survey, can I take those results as representative? What you have here is a self selecting pool of respondents. You simply can't make the jump from a self selected pool to any kind of general conclusion.


Comments
contest proves nothing
[James Watson] May 11, 2006 12:16:17.537
The whole contest proves nothing anyway. Writing the 'best' solution in 90 minutes is not a common skill people are looking for. In the 'real' world programming is a lot more than that.
It's kind of like pointing out that there are no American arithmetic champions. Who cares? If this kind of skill were important, 'Rain Man' would be the ultimate employee.