Smalltalk Tidbits, Industry Rants

Rogers Cadenhead has come up with a rather innovating anti-spam technique:

I'm trying a new technique this week that makes spam easy to detect by putting a bunch of bogus text areas on a weblog form, hiding them with Cascading Style Sheets, and checking them for input when the comment is submitted. I call these fields comment flak .

Spammers typically put their junk comment in every text area on a form. When text shows up in any of these flak fields, my blogging software treats it as spam.

That's a brilliant idea. I'll have to look into that.

Patrick Logan calls a spade a spade:

Seriously, Ruby is in dire need of a decent implementation. The JVM and the CLR are fine for what they are, old legacy. But Ruby needs its own *modern* implementation.

I'd love to have a Ruby implementation on our VM. The difficulty is in figuring out a business model that would support doing the investment.

Technorati Tags: JVM, CLR

Scoble quotes Jonathan Klein on the changes in the stock photo business being wrought by people like Thomas Hawk:

This is a business that’s seeing radical changes due to folks like Thomas. Thomas is an amateur. He gives his high-res images away for free, or for a low price if you want to use them commercially. He uses the same Canon 5D that other professionals are using. And, his images are often as good or better than the ones the pros are getting.

We know a semi-pro photographer (she helped my daughter's girl scout troop with a photography badge last year) who is running into the same thing, only she's far better prepared for those changes than the big photo warehouses like Getty are.

That's exactly what the music (and TV, and movie) businesses fear - becoming a commodity. The photo business is getting hit hard, because there's simply no way to lock up most photos. Some - of historical events - sure. There's going to be less and less of that as we go forward though, due to the sheer proliferation of good cameras. A decent amateur will be happy selling for a lot less than the pros do.

Now, as musical recording gets easier, we'll start to see some of the same thing happen. There are lots and lots of small bands that have no real interest in going pro - my cousin is in one. He has a wife and son, and doesn't really want to do the kind of road work that it would require. He also has a fulltime job, which makes music a hobby. As with photos, the band he's in would sell for a lot less than the pros and studios want to sell for - and they don't seem to be hung up on DRM, either.

It's going to be a rough transition for the studios to make, and they'll keep resisting it every inch of the way. In the end, I don't think they'll win. TV and movies - that will probably hold up longer. Doing quality story lines takes an actual budget - you have props, special effects, and - more importantly - time management. If you want to record a 2 hour movie that holds together, it's real work, and that requires paid time on the part of the people involved.

Technorati Tags: music, RIAA, MPAA

Sam Gentile links to a hilarious demonstration of how agile approaches can be stiffened right up, so long as you toss enough process at them :)

Technorati Tags: agile, tdd

Via Don Box, I see that Ruby 2.0 is dropping green threads and continuation support. Hmm - here's the pull quote from the place Don linked:

So what happened? Sometime around JavaOne we heard about the Ruby KaiGi in Japan, a Ruby conference or get-together of some sort. If RubyConf is the big conference for us Westerners, this at least provided a mid-year update for English-speaking Rubyists. Matz was there, Koichi was there, and I believe other Ruby dignitaries made the trip as well.

And then Matz and Koichi dropped the bomb: Ruby 2.0 would support neither continuations nor green threads.

I'm not so sure that's a good thing - it removes power from application developers, that's for sure. Anyone else have thoughts on that?

Technorati Tags: ruby, continuations, green threads

Scoble makes a call for a useful metric: engagement. What does that mean?

Well, I’ve compared notes with several bloggers and journalists and when the Register links to us we get almost no traffic. But they claim to have millions of readers. So, if millions of people are hanging out there but no one is willing to click a link, that means their audience has low engagement. The Register is among the lowest that I can see.

That sounds like a good measure, if we can get it. The trouble is, it's probably hard to get. Consider: I don't see much of an uptick in traffic when I get linked on various high traffic blogs, but I don't think it's due to non-engagement. Rather, it's due to a significant shared audience.

When a big social site - like Digg, Slashdot, or Reddit links to you, the overlap is smaller (in percentage terms), so you see a much bigger avalanche - from people who aren't aware that you exist. Over in the political sphere, it sounds like a link from Instapundit can have the same effect. So the measure Scoble wants would be highly useful, but I expect it'll be hard to get - it's in that "I know it when I see it" category, seems to me.

Technorati Tags: metrics

I love the idiotic chatter about A-Rod, and how his sub-par (not awful, just sub-par) season led the Yankees to disaster. ESPN reports that A-Rod won't be traded, which might just demonstrate that Cashman (Yankees GM) understand the real problem: pitching:

"Brian Cashman and I had a discussion and he made it clear that he has no intention of trading Alex," Boras told the Daily News, "and I told him that Alex Rodriguez has a no-trade clause.

"There will be no movement of Alex Rodriguez this offseason," Boras said.

However, baseball executives are unsure whether Boras' statements are believable, particularly given Rodriguez's postseason struggles and the media scrutiny in New York.

Here's the real problem, and it has Steinbrenner written all over it: how many decent young arms could have been picked up for the money they are shelling out to Randy Johnson? Johnson is my age, and - as I've said before - that's not a good thing. He's well past his prime, and his ERA shows that.

Let's say that they could have acquired 3-5 young arms for that money. If even 1 had worked out, the Yankees would be better off. Forget A-Rod. He's not the issue. The issue is pitching, period.

Technorati Tags: baseball, yankees

James McGovern makes an interesting point, although it might not be the one he was looking to make:

Many enterprisey folks aren't capable of researching the marketplace for themselves and therefore rely on large analyst firms to put things into nice charts and graphs for them. If the large analyst firms don't have enough integrity to also list open source projects in their matrix then enterprisey folks will not even learn about what benefits them.

That's a failure on so many levels. First, the people within the enterprise. If they can't research the market themselves, then management has a problem. Then there's management - why are they happy paying large dollar figures to large analyst firms just to get conventional wisdom? Some of the nimbler firms - Redmonk comes to mind - don't seem to fall into herd think.

Maybe those enterprisey folks should start doing some of the work themselves, so that they could draw their own conclusions.

Technorati Tags: management

Today's Smalltalk Daily continues the "walking tour" of the loadable components for VisualWorks.

Technorati Tags: smalltalk

Engadget notes the decidedly non-agile state of voting machine development:

Even though this flaw was evident as far back as 2002, secretary of the State Board of Elections Jean Jansen said she only recently became aware it; meanwhile Hart InterCivic can't touch the machines until it performs a system-wide firmware upgrade next year, and even that is contingent upon certification from state regulators.

I'm not sure how you would classify that kind of development cycle, but it sure isn't agile. There should be some kind of compromise position between "we can't touch it, ever" and "hack on it anytime".

Sci Fi Wire reports that Lost will be taking a mid-season hiatus:

ABC's hit series Lost will return for the second half of its third season on Feb. 7, after a 13-week hiatus; it will then run without repeats until the end of the season, Zap2it.com reported.

Sci Fi channel does a lot of that - BSG and the Stargates have operated this way for years. If the idea is to avoid reruns, I wonder if we'll start seeing pressure to move beyond the 20-26 episode season?

Andres Valloud lays out why he prefers dynamic typing. Agree or disagree, I think he makes a good case, and explains how and why he comes down on the side of dynamic typing.

Update: Andres followed up his own post with some additional thoughts.

Technorati Tags: static typing, dynamic typing, duck typing

Martin Fowler has a nice roundup of some of the better boardgames out there. My personal favorite right now is Caylus. It's a tile laying and resource management game, so it hits a number of interesting strategy points. A fascinating kicker is that turn order is not set - one of the available plays during the game is changing your position.

Caylus is not a beginner game though - if you are just getting started with this class of game, head over to Martin's place and read his recommendations.

Technorati Tags: Eurogames, boardgames

Don Park is not happy with Microsoft's WPF, and I can see why - his list of reasons hits some real issues. To wit:

WPF can't play Flash movies nor non-Microsoft movie formats seamlessly.

And

WPF is not available or problematic on non-Windows platforms.

Microsoft is still acting like they could "own" the internet space. That's kind of a blinkered view, and I think they're going to pay for that.

Technorati Tags: windows, microsoft

The other day, I was looking for a way to extract the audio from digital video - specifically, there are some video blogs - mostly interviews - that I'd like to listen to, but don't really want to be bothered with the video portion. Sure, I could put them up an iconify the video, but I do most of my podcast listening while jogging.

Anyway, Gary Short recommended Xilisoft Video Converter, which sells for about $20. I grabbed the demo, which allows you to convert up to five minutes worth. Seemed to work great, and the price is certainly right. I sure wish that amenable vlogs were available as both video and audio-only, but at least I can do that myself for stuff that looks interesting enough.

Via Brad Wilson, I found an interesting case of corporate segmentation taken to extremes: Sony put down a Hong Kong game vendor for selling outside their region:

Hong Kong, October 24th of 2006 - Lik-Sang.com, the popular gaming retailer from Hong Kong, has today announced that it is forced to close down due to multiple legal actions brought against it by Sony Computer Entertainment Europe Limited and Sony Computer Entertainment Inc. Sony claimed that Lik-Sang infringed its trade marks, copyright and registered design rights by selling Sony PSP consoles from Asia to European customers, and have recently obtained a judgment in the High Court of London (England) rendering Lik-Sang's sales of PSP consoles unlawful.

That sounds weird to me. It's getting to be more and more of a global market, especially for things like electronics. Sure, there are voltage differences (110 here in North America, 220 most everywhere else) - but the power bricks on game consoles and laptops are typically set to deal with both. This sounds like what Sony's on about:

Furthermore, Sony have failed to disclose to the London High Court that not only the world wide gaming community in more than 100 countries relied on Lik-Sang for their gaming needs, but also Sony Europe's very own top directors repeatedly got their Sony PSP hard or software imports in nicely packed Lik-Sang parcels with free Lik-Sang Mugs or Lik-Sang Badge Holders, starting just two days after Japan's official release, as early as 14th of December 2004 (more than nine months earlier than the legal action). The list of PSP related Sony Europe orders reads like the who's who of the videogames industry

There's still region based roll out for many things (especially with TV and movies). Looks like Sony is trying to play whack-a-mole with reality of global shipping. They won this case, but I don't think the war is winnable.

Technorati Tags: games, Sony

Looks like Smalltalk and Seaside are paying the bills over here:

Well, there are plenty of really neat ways to produce web applications. Most of you (like me) will work with php, mysql and probably enrich those with new AJAX features using one the available libraries like rico, SAJAX or script.aculo.us. Well, there is yet another way. Some of you may have heard about Smalltalk and/or are using it. It's a nice language and at the company I work everybody is using it or, to be more precise, we do most of our stuff in Squeak, which is build and run with Smalltalk.

Technorati Tags: Seaside, squeak

Soemirno Kartosoewito has started up a Smalltalk blog in Dutch, for all you Dutch speaking Smalltalkers.

Steve Gillmor says that TV is dead - the first paragraph is in reference to high end teleconferencing systems:

That's what this is about, tricking time, teleporting yourself across the country. We all wish Doc could actually enjoy his new house instead of rocketing off to Berkman one week a month. I could imagine the Gillmor Gang using the TelePort room from time to time. Remember that the next OS/X enables recording of iSight cons. It's on the way.

Meanwhile TV is dead. The kids still argue over carving out enough time to watch Heroes, the only consensus family show left alive.

Hmm. I think he has that very, very wrong. We have two ReplayTV devices, and a MediaCenter PC. They enable us to watch more of what we actually want to watch - the network cross programming games simply don't faze us anymore. There are plenty of great things on TV to watch, if you are so inclined. Battlestar Galactica, Dr. Who, Heroes - tons of interesting things across the history, science, and discovery channels. My wife and daughter love the medical shows, for instance.

What's dying is the traditional advertising model. Time shifting and the 30 second skip are wreaking havoc there, and the business is in flux as a result. It's not going to go away though, and the sheer spread of niche programming - both on the net and on cable - has made the space more interesting, not less.

Technorati Tags: advertising, media

Larry O'Brien explains how he unit tested his way to solving a performance problem. This part of his exploration is something I've learned the hard way:

As the race condition clobbered more threads, though, the relative amount of time each remaining thread spent inside the critical section decreased! Eventually the system would degrade to one or two threads, providing the illusion that the system was “limping along.” And making me ass-u-me that the problem had to do with the database.

That last sentence is the key thing: Most of us don't guess the problem at all well. Tools - whether tests or profilers (or, more likely, both) - help us identify the real problems.

Technorati Tags: testing, profiling, software development

I take a live and let live attitude toward religion - my beliefs can probably best be described as agnostic, tending to notional Christianity. Richard Dawkins, on the other hand, has decided that any religious belief is not only incorrect, but should be stamped out. If he wants to evangelize atheism, that's fine - more power to him. This (from Wired) is the road to you know where, paved with intentions that I'm not sure how to classify:

"How much do we regard children as being the property of their parents?" Dawkins asks. "It's one thing to say people should be free to believe whatever they like, but should they be free to impose their beliefs on their children? Is there something to be said for society stepping in? What about bringing up children to believe manifest falsehoods?"

Well, that's just great. He has his belief, which he cannot prove scientifically (he admits as much here):

"There's an infinite number of things that we can't disprove," he said. "You might say that because science can explain just about everything but not quite, it's wrong to say therefore we don't need God. It is also, I suppose, wrong to say we don't need the Flying Spaghetti Monster, unicorns, Thor, Wotan, Jupiter, or fairies at the bottom of the garden. There's an infinite number of things that some people at one time or another have believed in, and an infinite number of things that nobody has believed in. If there's not the slightest reason to believe in any of those things, why bother? The onus is on somebody who says, I want to believe in God, Flying Spaghetti Monster, fairies, or whatever it is. It is not up to us to disprove it."

Lacking an actual argument, he just goes ad homeneim. Great use of the scientific method there, dude. Based on the article, he seems to think that atheism will usher in a new age of reason, untainted by fanaticism. Here, he's pretty clear about that:

For the New Atheists, the problem is not any specific doctrine, but religion in general. Or, as Dawkins writes in The God Delusion, "As long as we accept the principle that religious faith must be respected simply because it is religious faith, it is hard to withhold respect from the faith of Osama bin Laden and the suicide bombers."

There was a movement that had that theory - perhaps Dawkins has heard of it. It worked out so well for the millions and millions of people sacrificed on that particular altar.

People like to believe in things. Remove deist belief, and that need won't go away - it will simply shift to some other kind of belief. Take a look at the far reaches of the environmental movement, for instance - if that's not secular religion, then nothing is. Dawkins has an abiding faith in the idea that "reason" can save people from fanaticism. History simply doesn't bear that out. The Soviet Communists and the German Nazis didn't kill for God - but kill they did. I fail to see how Dawkins' faith is any better than the people who walk my neighborhood handing out pamphlets. At the very least, they aren't trying to get children forcibly removed in order to teach them a "higher truth".

Technorati Tags: religion, belief

The Squeakers have gotten EToys on the OLPC (One laptop Per Child). Very cool news; it will get Smalltalk some positive PR.

Technorati Tags: squeak, olpc

Ze Frank makes a good point about web ratings, and what you can validly make of them (not much). Right now, you should take any web stats you see with a huge pile of salt.

Technorati Tags: ratings

Today's Smalltalk Daily starts looking at the loadable components for VisualWorks. There's a lot of them, and we only get through a handful today.

Technorati Tags: smalltalk

Ed Foster spots more excitement in the Vista EULA - the rules governing benchmarking, and what you can say about it:

But the bigger problem is the fact that the actual censorship restrictions for Windows Vista are, in classic sneakwrap fashion, dependent on what a particular webpage says at a particular moment. That in itself could have a chilling effect on what people can say about Vista. Consumers who don't even know what .NET Framework is will, if they want to make sure any public statements they make about Vista "comply with the conditions" of Microsoft's license, have to first decipher what that webpage means. And, of course, Microsoft could change the conditions at any time, so you'll have to check back anytime you make any more comments about Vista. Perhaps as written now it's OK for you to tell your neighbor over the back fence that Vista seems to take twice as long to boot up as MacOS XI, but what if Redmond changes the conditions at some point in the future to prohibit such activities?

The internal takeover by lawyers seems nearly complete up in Redmond. This happened at IBM, too - and they went through an awfully rough patch before they came out on the other side of that.

Technorati Tags: Vista, Microsoft

Phil Windley notes that video podcasting is a different animal than audio:

Brett comments that when he's at his computer watching video its far more likely to be YouTube than it is a video podcast on technology 'ala the Scobleshow. Audio podcasts compete with radio, music, or, in some cases, non-consumption (i.e. the fill time that the listener wouldn't be listening to anything else). This doesn't change with better video iPods.

For me, it's like this: I jog between 35-60 minutes at lunchtime every day. I can listen to audio then. Even if my iPod could handle video (it's an old mini), I couldn't watch it - I'm paying attention to my surroundings. When I'm back at my desk, I can have audio up while I'm working - but video requires most of my attention. So a 5 minute YouTube clip, or something of similar duration - sure, I can find time for that. A long interview? Not a chance.

Now, I know some people prefer video, but why not provide a separate audio link, and see what your download stats look like? I could be wrong, but I'd bet that the audio files will be hit harder.

Technorati Tags: vlog

We had a small outage this afternoon - it seems one of the images posted on Troy's blog was linked over at MySpace, and it was being served dynamically (rather than statically). That caused a few problems. Everything is back to normal now, and we are in the process of trying to prevent that particular problem from cropping up again.

Technorati Tags: downtime

Arden Thomas explains how he used an RDBMS for object schema migration in a past job - and how they used Opentalk to optimize the interactions

Technorati Tags: smalltalk, O/R

Jeff Jarvis quotes a Times story on the way to concluding that the Hollywood/TV machine is "imploding":

The quick cancellation of “Smith” elucidates how television, like the movie industry, has become a business where there is little room for the modest success. Network executives might talk endlessly about how, in an era where the attention of audiences is ever more scattered, new shows need time to find themselves. But those same executives are often quick to pull the plug on an expensive production that does not immediately perform to expectations.

Not so fast, Jeff. I watched a little over half of the first episode, and I can tell you why I stopped - the "heroes" of the story are a bunch of slimeballs. In the first episode, as they rip off a museum, they kill a guard who's just doing his job. I have no ability to sympathize with that kind of plot line; none at all. I might be an outlier on that, but with that show, I really hope I was in the majority. I say good riddance to that, and I'd be happy to learn that the writers involved never work again.

Technorati Tags: media

Rogers Cadenhead is being threatened with a lawsuit by conspiracy nut Art Bell - over comments made to his blog. Rogers notes that part of the CDA protects him from having to police those comments:

Though I give readers wide latitude in the comments they post, I remove libelous comments when they're called to my attention, as I told him in our email exchange. But I'm under no legal obligation to do so, thanks to Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act

I think Rogers should be get support if he gets sued over this - no one wants to live in fear of commenters wrecking their lives.

Peter Fisk identifies the crux of Microsoft's problem:

Their problem isn’t a lack of talent, it is a lack of direction - and no amount of hiring is going to fix it.

I always figured that MS would be ok, so long as Gates was having fun. Whenever that ended, and he moved on to something else - the company was going to start drifting. It looks like I wasn't wrong. This doesn't imply that MS is "doomed", or anything - but I think they are going to end up sliding through the same tunnel of malaise that IBM went through during the 80's and early 90's.

Technorati Tags: Microsoft

Today's Smalltalk Daily covers BOSS schema migration.

Technorati Tags: smalltalk

Lessig may have his heart in the right place, but he's awfully unrealistic. I grow increasingly tired of the "but they have better broadband in (insert country here)" arguments:

I. and many, have concluded it is not. I take it, that is the view of the more than a million who have written to policy-makers arguing for network neutrality legislation. These people want policy that will finally push broadband providers to provide at least the quality and price of broadband in France. The online campaign to get Congress to do something here has been amazing, rivaling only the campaign to stop the FCC from passing rules that would permit even more concentration in media ownership.

Perhaps Lessig could pull out a map. If he did, he might notice that France is roughly the size of Texas, and that we have 49 other states besides. That's a lot less territory in which to pull cables. He might consider what net neutrality laws would accomplish in practice, as opposed to his theory. In practice, a real congressional committee (with real lobbyists) would push something through, and then the various providers would start fishing for interesting ways to take advantage of it. Under the current system, with no law in that area, public pressure on particularly egregious acts can work. Under Lessig's system, every provider would answer complaints this way:

We're just following the law; direct your complaints to Congress

Yeah Larry, that's a huge improvement. Thanks so much for trying to take an admittedly bad system and screw it up even worse. Do the rest of us a favor - stop advocating for law in this area. You just might get your wish, and the rest of us will spend years regretting it.

Technorati Tags: net neutrality, broadband

This is funny - I especially likes this bit:

If someone drops a Smalltalk book on your desk, and you start to shiver uncontrollably, your eyes rolling back in your head as strange gutteral voices shout from your throat ‘Never! I shall never release his soul!' - you might be a Blub programmer

Heh :)

Scoble comments on Tim Bray's F Bomb dropping:

Personally I think it’s cool that Tim Bray thinks Sun’s new product is cool enough to use salty language about.

Actually, it's very much not cool, and I'm utterly unimpressed with Bray's handwaving about it. Here's the thing: when you use coarse language, there's no upside. That's right - none. At best, part of your audience won't care, or won't care that much. It's an absolute certainty that some of your audience (who knows how much) will be put off by it.

In marketing terms, that's a pretty large net negative. No one (or, almost no one) is going to have a positive reaction. Some people will blip past it. However, some of your readers (or listeners) will be offended - possibly enough to damage the way they look at your product, service or company.

So no, that usage wasn't cool, not by a longshot. The best we can say about it is that it might not do much damage. For those of you who think such usage is somehow more "authentic", I have two words: grow up.

Technorati Tags: PR

James McGovern should actually read what Yegge wrote, and compare it to the process heavy stuff that goes on in most enterprises. He might even learn something - but I'll keep my expectations low.

Technorati Tags: stupidity

The US government has banned Vegemite?

The bizarre crackdown was prompted because Vegemite has been deemed illegal under US food laws.

The great Aussie icon - faithfully carried around the world by travellers from downunder - contains folate, which under a technicality, America allows to be added only to breads and cereals.

Say what? What moron decided to do this?

Technorati Tags: vegemite

Andres Valloud has been keeping up with Smalltalkers and Smalltalk related goings on at OOPLSA.

Technorati Tags: OOPSLA

Jeff Jarvis charts the ongoing decline of the newspaper business - it's been a bad week for the news business. In reading through the cuts and changes, I realized that I was reading a proxy for the fears of the RIAA (and eventually, the MPAA).

The news business is changing, due to a number of related events:

• The non-stop, 24x7 news cycle that the cable news outlets can cover
• The availability of 24x7 news online - delivered in ways that fit nearly any ideological or taste niche

Daily newspapers can't keep up with that unless they go digital - and that business is mostly ad supported (as opposed to ad and subscription supported). The music business sees that same thing coming at them - a digital juggernaught of ad-supported, no copy protection data files. The margins there are a lot lower, and (literally) thousands of the current middle men have no place in that future.

The newspapers can't fight the future with DRM and the DMCA; they have to adapt, no matter how painful and gut wrenching that adaptation is. The music business, thus far, has taken the "preserve our business model at all costs" route instead. When their fall comes, it will be all the more catastrophic for them, because they'll have been living in denial for too long.

Technorati Tags: music, DRM, DMCA, RIAA, MPAA

Scoble points to the last Gillmore Gang - Dana Gardner and Jason Calacanis got into a pretty good fight over public/private charity. I started listening to that a week ago while jogging; I've actually looked into some of the issues they were arguing over, and was a teacher 20 years ago. I stopped listening, because every additional second I listened, I lost respect for Gardner. Why?

He was arguing that Jason Calacanis' entirely admirable efforts to rescue a few children from bad schools was an act of evil, designed to "destroy" public education. That's a really, really stupid argument, without regard to what issue you try and deploy it against. The bottom line is, any effort to help people in need is admirable, and Jason should be saluted for caring enough to try. Gardner can go suck eggs. When you let ideology (of any stripe) blind you to good acts, you've lost some of your humanity.

Technorati Tags: Calacanis, Gardener, Gillmor Gang

This is pretty cool. Follow the link to see what the actors saw, as opposed to what Sam and Frodo saw, when they first caught site of Mount Doom.

Michael, David, and I got together this morning and had a chat about image based development - and responded to some listener email. This week's topic: Image based development and deployment. Stay tuned at the end for James Savidge's Smalltalk Jobs Report. You can grab the mp3 here - this week's chat was nearly 45 minutes.

If you have feedback, send it to smalltalkpodcasts@cincom.com. If you send an mp3 file, we'll try to play it on the air.

Technorati Tags: smalltalk

Nick Carr is truly a curmudgeon - in a post about Google, he wraps up with this:

Those Japanese commodes are nice, but it's important to remember that they're merely transitional devices. We'll know that Google has truly fulfilled its vision when the Googleplex no longer needs toilets at all.

Technorati Tags: humor

It's time for the weekly look at the logs. BottomFeeder downloads were at 182/day last week; the details:

Platform	BottomFeeder Downloads
Windows	549
Update	230
Linux x86	153
Mac X	121
CE ARM	73
Mac 8/9	48
Solaris	29
HPUX	20
Windows98/ME	14
Sources	11
Linux Sparc	10
AIX	10
SGI	4
ADUX	3
Linux PPC	1

Next, the HTML traffic. Total site traffic was up again, which is always good:

Tool	Percentage of Accesses
Internet Explorer	46.2%
Mozilla	40.2%
Planet Smalltalk	4.9%
Other	4.6%
MSN Bot	2%
Megite	1.1%
Opera	1%

IE 7 use must be up - or my audience demographics are changing. Last, the RSS distribution:

Tool	Percentage of Accesses
BottomFeeder	21%
Mozilla	19.9%
Other	11.2%
Net News Wire	8.2%
Safari RSS	6.4%
Internet Explorer	6%
Google Feed Fetcher	5.6%
BlogLines	4%
NewsGator	3.3%
Planet Smalltalk	1.9%
RSS Bandit	1.7%
Akregator	1.6%
MSN Bot	1.1%
News Fire	1.1%
JetBrains	1.1%
Liferea	1%
Opera	1%
SharpReader	1%
RSS 2 Email	1%
Python	1%
Feed Reader	1%
Jakarta	1%

Whenever the bright boys at the RIAA wonder why the public hates them, they might look at stories like this one: a firmware update to the Zen Vision:M product disabled the FM radio capability, due to "copyright issues". Yeah - recording songs off the radio, complete with the station lead-in and out is really a threat to music sales. There's a reason people don't have any respect for these clowns; they don't deserve any respect.

Technorati Tags: music, law, RIAA

Jeff Jarvis spots a nascent trend in the newspaper business:

Virtually every major paper is making the shift to local coverage, often as it cuts deeper into editorial operations. Only recently, the Dallas Morning News announced it was closing its national bureaus while cutting 20 percent of its newsroom staff. It was becoming a local paper again after several decades of rising stature for its national and international coverage. More than 100 people were let go.

Similar, if less dramatic, changes are taking place at such papers as The Washington Post, New Jersey’s Bergen Record and Herald News, and the Richmond Times Dispatch. And joining them all is Gannett, the largest newspaper chain and publisher of USA Today.

“We’re going to get hyper-local,” says Tara Connell, a Gannett spokesperson.

I'm not sure what that means for USA Today, but it makes a lot of sense for other papers. I can get national and international news from a bunch of sources, and my local paper is not the first place I'd look for that stuff. On the other hand, who else is going to cover the local crime beat, or the meetings of the local county council? The national networks won't do that stuff, nor will the newswires. The local papers could do that, and they could easily do it better than anyone else.

It doesn't even have to cost that much - local reporters won't command (or even need - you might well get by with a bunch of stringers interested in specific local areas) nearly the salary requirements of a "big" reporter. It's back to the future time for local media, and not a minute too soon, IMHO.

Technorati Tags: news

Scoble lays out the issues with making money for online video solely through advertising:

Here’s the trouble. Most people I know are getting advertising revenues of between $10 and $40 CPM. That means that for every 1,000 people who visit a Web site, an advertiser is paying somewhere around $10 usually (often less, and in some cases, far less — Jeremy Wright told me he was only getting about $.50 CPM when he runs Google’s ad bar).

Now, that sounds great, particularly if you can get a big audience and when you write a blog that has minimum creation costs (yeah, some posts take hours, but others can be done in minutes and you don’t need anything but a computer to do this). That low cost of production is why Jason Calacanis was able to create $25 million in value by lashing together 100 bloggers. But, let’s look deeper at video.

First, the videos I’m putting up are around 200MB a piece. The bandwidth distributors I know are charging $.14 or more PER GIGABYTE to distribute those videos. So, that comes to $28, or more for 1,000 downloads (if my math is right).

That's going to be a problem, I think. It's just going to be very hard to get arbitrary video segments paid for - sponsorship works, but does have strings (implicit or otherwise). For those of us using podcasts and screencasts strictly for promotional purposes, this isn't really an issue - it's just part of the overall marketing budget. For others, it's currently a challenge.

Technorati Tags: advertising, video

I have an an idea for Smalltalk user groups - if you can record your meetings (hopefully with compelling speakers), I'll be happy to post the recordings in my podcast feed. Just send me an audio file (compressed in a zip or gzip would be best). I'd advise sending any such things to my gmail address, as the Cincom email filter might well eat the attachment.

Awhile back, Scott McNealy said "Privacy is dead, deal with it". That got a lot of play at the time, but fell into bit bucket over time.

Today, Bruce Schneier explains just how far reaching that assumption is:

Everyday conversation used to be ephemeral. Whether face-to-face or by phone, we could be reasonably sure that what we said disappeared as soon as we said it. Of course, organized crime bosses worried about phone taps and room bugs, but that was the exception. Privacy was the default assumption.

This has changed. We now type our casual conversations. We chat in e-mail, with instant messages on our computer and SMS messages on our cellphones, and in comments on social networking Web sites like Friendster, LiveJournal and News Corp.'s (nyse: NWS - news - people ) MySpace. These conversations--with friends, lovers, colleagues, fellow employees--are not ephemeral; they leave their own electronic trails.

We know this intellectually, but we haven’t truly internalized it. We type on, engrossed in conversation, forgetting that we’re being recorded.

This goes well beyond any legal worries over government monitoring. That sounds like I'm back burnering that issue, and - for the purposes of a larger point, I am. Let me start with an example.

I communicate with other Cincomers (and a variety of other people) via an IRC channel. I'm on that channel most of the time, and the traffic is all being logged - both by my IRC client, and probably by every other IRC client. Ten years from now, someone who I've had a falling out with could dredge up some extended bout of silliness we engage in from time to time, take it out of context, and embarrass me greatly. Heck, it might go beyond embarrassment - if it was stupid enough "bathroom humor", it might do actual damage.

IM is another communication channel I use, along with email. Email is persistent, and IM logs can be saved. There's no telling what someone could do with an out of context message (or, an in context one made under a presumption of privacy). As Bruce says above, we operate as if we're engaged in an "over the fence" chat, only these are all logged, and could come back to haunt us.

I'm grateful that I didn't have blogs, email, IM, and IRC chats to leave a paper trail on me when I was in college - today's students do though, and their transient acts of silliness - acts that would have dropped into the ether 20 years ago - could easily come back to haunt them in 2 or 3 decades. I fully expect politicians to get chased by decades old logs in the coming years, and for political battles at corporations to work the same way.

Unlike Bruce, I don't really think legislation will help much. I chat with people in other countries on the Smalltalk IRC channel all the time. US law won't mean anything to them. Likewise, overseas emails and IMs won't be affected by whatever privacy regime Schneier idealizes. Ultimately, I think we are going to have to internalize the new reality of a logged world. I'd recommend a book - James Halperin's "The Truth Machine". part of the world built in that book is a constant logging (video, audio, etc) of everything - mostly by people themselves.

Technorati Tags: privacy

Looks to me like the recording industry finally figured out that the law wasn't the best attack vector for going after allofmp3.com - instead, they hit them directly in the wallet: Visa and Mastercard have announced that they will no longer process payments there.

That's going to affect their behavior a lot more than arcane negotiations at the trade talk level ever would have.

Technorati Tags: law, copyright

In today's Smalltalk Daily, I look at a better way to serialize objects to disk: the BOSS package.

Technorati Tags: smalltalk, object serialization

Scoble notes that many people don't use the Yellow Pages anymore:

Geoff reports he doesn’t. I don’t even know where mine are. I’d hate to work there, although there’s still money left in that old model cause there’s still lots of people who don’t look to their computers for everything.

Most of those people, though, are older than me. That means that business model has 20 years left in it, if that.

It really depends on what you're looking for. Need an electrician to come out and look at something? You can waste time in Google trying to narrow the search, or you can open the big yellow book to "E", and find what you need in seconds. For an awful lot of local businesses - electricians, plumbers, that kind of thing - the Yellow Pages are still far more efficient.

Technorati Tags: advertising

Peter Fisk needs a small correction hee:

A company which did survive the transition was Digitalk which did an absolutely brilliant job of porting Smalltalk/V to Windows. After writing Windows applications in C, the experience of using Digitalk Smalltalk (1.0 and 2.0) was a total liberation. Forget about the mixed-mode pointers; make a window? - no problem! And I wasn’t the only one to feel that way. By the end of 1994, there was a thriving community of Digitalk developers.

Of course, it didn’t last - Digitalk never brought out a 32-bit version.
Unfortunately, Digitalk never enjoyed the same success with their 32-bit offerings.

In fact, not only did they bring out a 32 bit version, they brought out a Windows/95 logo certified edition - Visual Smalltalk (and the enterprise edition, VSE). Digitalk then merged with ParcPlace, and things got all wonky (no need to go into that here). Point is, not only did Digitalk come out with a 32 bit edition - they got out early, and got it logo certified.

Update: Peter corrected his post.

Technorati Tags: VSE, Digitalk

Wendy Seltzer explains in detail why you would be absolutely nuts to upgrade to Vista. head on over there for details, but I love the lede:

Reading the Windows Vista license is a bit like preparing for breakfast with Lewis Carroll's Red Queen: You should be ready to believe at least six impossible things about what users want from software.

I agree with her - those terms are utterly absurd. I shouldn't have to register my software, and MS shouldn't care if I install new components in my PC. With this, they've now reached the same levels of titanic stupidity that IBM attained in the late 80's.

Technorati Tags: license, EULA, Vista, Microsoft

Is sanity starting to pop up inside the music industry? The WSJ seems to imply that it might be:

But now there's a growing recognition among some record executives and performers that the people who are downloading illegally are frequently huge music fans and that marketing to them may be more desirable in the long run than suing or otherwise harassing them.

Whoa, that might be too much thinking all at once for these clowns. Still, it's progress - they seem to realize that their bozo tactics aren't working, and the people downloading are fans. Many of whom would grab music legally, given the right incentives (i.e., if the market actually responded to the public feedback). So this, while it's condescending, is at least moving in the right direction:

Hence the alliance between Jay-Z and Coke. By inserting promotional material into the decoy files, and then planting those files prominently on file-sharing sites, record labels and other marketers can turn what is now an antipiracy tool into an advertising medium. "The concept here is making the peer-to-peer networks work for us," says Jay-Z's attorney, Michael Guido. "While peer-to-peer users are stealing the intellectual property, they are also the active music audience," and "this technology allows us to market back to them."

That Google ad thing might be inspiring them. I'd call this a fluke, but Disney recently showed signs of intelligence as well:

"We understand now that piracy is a business model," says Sweeney during the Keynote address at Mipcom. "It exists to serve a need in the market for consumers who want TV content on demand. Pirates compete the same way we do - through quality, price and availability. We we don’t like the model but we realize it’s competitive enough to make it a major competitor going forward."

Umm, yeah. The Buzz Out Loud crew has been pointing out for eons that most people would prefer to stay legal - if only the industry didn't try to shove crapware (DRM) down their throats. Tapes didn't kill CD sales, and DAT wouldn't have either. Downloads won't kill the for profit music sector, unless the studios keep being morons.

The RIAA has taken a quarter step in that direction:

This week the MPAA's CTO Brad Hunt had his own realization: "I understand that if we frustrate the consumer, they will simply pirate the content." He then goes on to explore how the MPAA is pushing for some degree of DRM interoperability

DRM is the problem, which is why I call it a quarter step. They seem to be aware that there's a problem; that's better. Next, they need to recognize that DRM is a bug, not a solution.

Now, before I start sounding all sunshiney on this, there is bad news: The IFPI (think international version of the RIAA) is suing anything that moves:

THE music industry has launched a new wave of 8000 lawsuits against alleged file-sharers around the world.

The International Federation of the Phonographic Industry (IFPI), which represents the world's music companies, said the new cases were brought in 17 countries, including the first ones ever in Brazil, Mexico and Poland.

I guess there has to be a conservation of cluelessness.

Technorati Tags: DRM, RIAA

I found this post on "languages that suck" interesting. There's a small issue with the metric used to find Smalltalk though. I'm not going to argue that Smalltalk is "mainstream", but it does have a bigger footprint than this site would suggest. How so?

Well, one of the metrics is the availability of code files online:

As in the first study, all data were collected from search results retrieved via Google's Code Search. For each target language, three pieces of information were initially gathered:

Total Files

An approximation of the language's footprint in Google's database (and thus its popularity). Determined by one of the following queries: lang:<language-name>, lang:"<language-name>", or file:.*\.ext where ext is the file extension of that language's source code files.

Here's the problem - Smalltalkers don't tend to share source code that way - especially in the two dialects that get a lot of attention online: Squeak and Cincom Smalltalk. For Squeak, there's a lot of stuff shared via SqueakMap, and for CST, there's the Public Store. Neither is going to show up in this kind of search. As well, Smalltalk source files don't have a standard file extension across dialects (or even a completely interchangeable source format).

Something to keep in mind.

Update: You can look at some package detail for the Public Store here (475 packages listed) and for SqueakMap here (669).

Technorati Tags: smalltalk

Scoble is giving IE 7 a whirl:

But IE7 does have some challenges ahead of it. Some sites in it render very slow. Most notably for me, Google Reader. I’m also using the new Firefox 2 and Firefox is a LOT faster. IE7 is frustratingly slow on Google Reader. It seems to hang whenever new stuff is being downloaded in the background via AJAX. To be fair, Google is probably pushing the browser in all sorts of ways, even the MSN team decided to back off on its use of AJAX due to speed problems, though (Live.com used to have an infinite scroll capability, which I really loved but they got rid of it after speed complaints came in).

I can't speak to this directly; I haven't grabbed IE 7 yet. What worries me about IE 7 has to do with the internal websites here at Cincom. When I tried one of the betas, it simply didn't work with our main intranet site. It may well be fine now, but I'm a bit leery.

Technorati Tags: IE7, Firefox

The best argument against "net neutrality" legislation was something Jerry Pournelle said on last week's TWiT podcast. To summarize (this is not an exact quote), he asked whether we should trust the Congress to write a law (any law, on either side of this) that would not have some fairly horrid unintended consequences. Never mind the intended consequences.

I know I don't. I'd rather have no new law in this area at all.

Technorati Tags: net neutrality, web

David Buck announces a Vista Smalltalk presentation in Ottawa, November 1st. I wish I could justify a trip up to see that!

Technorati Tags: smalltalk, Vista

I just got bitten by a browser incompatibility I didn't know about - IE doesn't do "onclick" handlers in menus. Since I just changed over to that, it's kind of a problem. So, I now detect the browser agent and feed IE 6 the older (long) lists. Sorry about the break.

Technorati Tags: blog

In today's Smalltalk Daily, I take a look at writing binary files.

Technorati Tags: smalltalk

I commented on a "Java dynamic code" post earlier, and got a few comments - so I pushed up a screencast showing how to generate new code (methods and classes) at runtime in Smalltalk. It's way, way simpler than the Java example, and I show that in the screencast. Watch it here; enjoy.

Technorati Tags: java, smalltalk, dynamic languages

In other pretzel twisting, see how much of an unnatural act you have to commit to get something vaguely like "duck typing" in Java.

As I said earlier today, I'll be over here, being productive. You Java guys knock yourselves out.

Technorati Tags: duck typing, dynamic languages, smalltalk

Doc Searls sums up what needs to be said about PayPerPost:

Yesterday I said PayPerPost makes you an ass****. Your job is to serve s***. You reduce yourself from a human being to an orifice for excreting messages. That may have seemed extreme or unkind; but hey, what's the difference between that and showing up on a bull**** detector?

What more needs to be added?

Technorati Tags: marketing, advertising, integrity

There's Dynamic as done in Java, and then there's the real thing, as I do it in my blog server all the time (just this morning, in fact). Code that didn't exist when I first wrote the server? No problem. Replacing methods as the server runs? No problem. Creating new code and just loading it? How do you think the recent addition of iTunes tag support (necessary before I could get the podcasts listed in iTunes and other podcast directories) loaded? I wrote the code, tested it, and had the server load the results. Suddenly the RSS generator was dropping new meta information out.

Here's an old post on how I do the same thing in a client. On the server, the steps are as follows:

• Create new code in my test environment
• Once it works, export the diffs between the old version and the new one (i.e. a Smalltalk file-in for patches to existing code, or a new parcel for completely new stuff)
• On the server, create a small script to load the changes
• Hit the script, have the changes load. On the fly, as the server runs

That's it. No need to write code in some custom fashion to deal with things that didn't exist before - the Smalltalk system just accepts that they're there, and deals with it. This is yet another example of the mental cruft you have to deal with in a language like Java. In Smalltalk, that cruft just doesn't exist.

I'll be over here, being productive. You Java guys can read the multi-page post on how to do the same thing in your world :)

Technorati Tags: smalltalk, development, cincom smalltalk, dynamic languages

Steve Rubel notes that advertising dollars seem to be getting lower. I say "seem to be", because it's based on an analyst report (Blackfriars Communications), and I know nothing about them. Anyway, here's what Steve notes:

Actual dollars spent on advertising this year was sharply lower than the original estimates. This according to an analysis by Blackfriars Communications. Worse, the same story is true online.

Researchers had predicted that 10% of overall advertising spending this year would go online. Meanwhile, it ended up at 7% of budgets. Plus, the entire pie shrunk as well.

That could be air leaking out of the web 2.0 bubble. We'll probably know within a few months, one way or the other. One thing's for sure - a lot of startups are very, very dependent on ad revenue. Could Yahoo's difficulties there be an early warning sign?

Technorati Tags: web2.0

I just made a small change to the behavior here on the site. You'll notice the enormous lists of category and syndication lists have been shrunken down to pull menus. Michael suggested that to me last night (to be fair, Vassili has mentioned it more than once too). In any case, it's done now - the sidebars should be easier to navigate.

In today's Smalltalk Daily, we look at the process of writing external files.

Technorati Tags: smalltalk

Here's one of the problems with outsourcing your manufacturing widely - you really need to be careful about quality checks. Otherwise, you get things like the iPod virus fiasco:

The company said that a small number of video iPods made after Sept. 12 included the RavMonE virus. It said it has seen fewer than 25 reports of the problem, which it said does not affect other models of the media player, nor does it affect Macs.

From a PR perspective, Apple did the right thing by taking responsibility (and even managed to get a shot in at MS in the process):

"As you might imagine, we are upset at Windows for not being more hardy against such viruses, and even more upset with ourselves for not catching it," Apple said on its site.

THis doesn't mean that you should run a vertical stack like Henry Ford did back in the 1920's - but it does mean that you need to "trust, but verify" rather than just "trust".

Technorati Tags: manufacturing, quality assurance

Michel Bany, the Cincomer who has ported Seaside from Squeak to VW, gives some tips on loading it:

Bundles SeasideForWebToolkit and SeasideForSwazoo are containers for a script that loads the actual Seaside bundles choosing bundles with similar version numbers.

The Seaside bundles can also be loaded manually in the following sequence :

1. Seaside-VW
2. Seaside
3. Seaside-WebToolkit or Seaside-Swazoo

In this case you may load whatever versions you want, for instance :

1. Seaside-VW 2.6b1.103
2. Seaside 2.6b1.103
3. Seaside-Swazoo 2.6b1.84

There may be some issues with the Seaside servlet at present; that's being looked at.

Technorati Tags: seaside, smalltalk