Top Smalltalkers - Eclipse isn't better

I spotted this in comp.lang.smalltalk:

You'll have to attend Smalltalk Solutions this year to see John O'Keefe and Eric Clayberg attempt to convince us that we should drop Smalltalk IDE's in favour of Eclipse, even for Smalltalk development.

To which Eric Clayberg responds:

Yikes! If you come to Smalltalk Solutions expecting to see a talk like that, you will be disappointed.

BTW, I did a talk last year at SS'02 on "Eclispe for Smalltalkers". You can see the presentation here:

http://www.instantiations.com/sts/files/Eclipse4Smalltalkers.pdf