Send to Printer

blog

Over the Edge

August 20, 2006 17:24:48.388

Kent Newsome has been engaged in an interesting conversation over the shape and form of the blogosphere, but I think he's gone off the deep end with his latest post:

Which I think means that the more people who have access to the blogosphere, the more control will flow down blogger's hill, which will make the disenfranchised bloggers happier, which will be good for the blogosphere as a whole. There is certainly mathematical truth to the first two parts of that statement and it sounds like the words of a valiant, if idealistic, social reformer. But it is also self-evident that merely being included in a population, be it bloggers or citizens, does not end the struggle for equal opportunity. Sure, power shifts naturally as water flows naturally. But there's more to it than that. The efforts of those upstream, be they the ruling class or the dam builders, can impair and corrupt the process. To say that the natural effects of inclusion will solve the problem without further effort is to abandon a battle half won.

Here's a hot news flash: Life isn't Fair. It's not going to start being fair, either. Heck, the above makes as much sense as me demanding equal time for Smalltalk: "Hey, there's too much Java development going on, and that's not fair. Some of those projects simply must start using Smalltalk, in order to ensure equal opportunity for development languages".

Yeah, that's going to happen. No one is entitled to a large pool of readers - and a lack of them isn't a problem that needs solving. I have no idea where Kent is trying to go with that post - but let me ask this: what's the proposed solution?

Technorati Tags:

Comments

From the Deep End

[Kent Newsome] August 20, 2006 18:05:44.825

Thanks for the link.

As I tried to say in the first paragraph of that post, I'm not really trying to change the way the blogosphere works.  I simply feel compelled to drive my truck through the giant holes in the logic of those who keep trying to tell everyone that it works differently than it does.

I would summarize the point I am trying to make the way I did at the end of another post the other day:  The blogosphere is not an equal opportunity place. Life isn't either. It's OK that they aren't, as long as you don't try to pretend they are.

The problems don't arise from saying "yes, it is a problem, but that's just the way life works."  The problems arise when someone says, as a few did recently, "There's no problem and anyone who sees a problem is an idiot." 

 Share Tweet This