Send to Printer

marketing

Depends on the definition of "better"

April 8, 2006 19:58:31.528

Mark Bernstein:

Can brilliant marketing beat superior engineering? If you meet someone who advocates this, I think you may have just met a sales consultant who wants to sell you a bridge.

And further down:

If you believe that marketing beats engineering, talk to some of the Madison avenue folks who tried to defend the railroads and the steamships against air travel.

Well, I suppose it depends on the full definition of "better". IMNSHO, Smalltalk is vastly better than Java. However, Java is (mostly) free, and it has the advantage of being similar (syntactically) to C and C++. Thus, in engineering terms, Java is what you might call an 80% solution that counts as "good enough" for a lot of people. And yes - good marketing around an 80% solution will beat lesser marketing around a 95% solution every day of the week.

Comments

[] April 8, 2006 21:10:19.750

I think the Panda Principle has some relevance here.

...the first one was a couple of weeks ago when I decided to pick up a Smalltalk book from Stephane Ducasse's collection and learn the language. Smalltalk is a fascinating and beautiful language. It was destined to be the next best thing. Then came Java. We all know what happened next...

 Share Tweet This