RSS and Bandwidth
There's more stuff out there on RSS and bandwidth:
RSS Bandwidth Usage We're all starting to see the inevitable issues with RSS bandwidth usage. Something that occurred to me in the shower that I haven't heard anyone talk about (although I am a veritable newbie compared to people like Dave Winer, Ben Hammersley, Bill Kearney and others) was can the feed itself specify the allowed polling interval ? I.e. if you're me and you update your blog constantly then I'd want to allow a fast polling interval but a lot of us don't update as frequently and they could set a daily interval. Or has this been hashed out, discussed and I'm just clue free ? And yeah I know that some aggregators would ignore it but it could be implemented as a default setting that the user manually forced if they needed to. The same way you can force a browser to refresh.
IMHO, the whole feed polling thing is a hack. BottomFeeder supports it, but there's a simpler answer (which Bf also supports) - conditional-get. You send a small query to the Http server and ask if the doc has been updated. If it hasn't, you get a documented answer, and you don't fetch the whole ything.
This is the prior art - it was invented years ago to solve scalability issues at the server. Http already has an answer to this problem. the various proposals to implement hacks with update intervals on fully dynamic feeds will make the problem worse, not better - let the Http server do what it's good at, and push out a static feed. Have aggregators do the right thing, and check for updates before pulling the whole feed. It ought to be simpler to have aggregators support the existing infrastructure (which works, btw) than to support some new thing which purports to solve the same problem.

Comments
Untitled
[Georg Bauer] May 19, 2003 12:09:46.704
My reply is at: http://pyds.muensterland.org/weblog/2003/05/19.html#P121 BTW: your Trackback seems broken, I just get a server error when trying to trackback ping your entry. bye, Georg
Re: RSS and Bandwidth
[Rich Demers] May 19, 2003 12:30:37.076
Comment on RSS and Bandwidth by Rich Demers
Two ideas I like for keeping RSS bandwith to a minimum:: 1. The servers give the aggregators hints as to when it makes sense to check for updates. Whether the aggs pay attention to the hints, and whether the servers enforce them, are separate issues. Best if everyone cooperates and do not get too authoritarian! 2. Aggregators request only the items changeed since a lastUpdateDate, servers provide only those items, and aggs cache earlier items.
Re: Re: RSS and Bandwidth
[Michael Lucas-Smith] May 19, 2003 18:46:47.676
Comment on Re: RSS and Bandwidth by Michael Lucas-Smith
2. Aggregators request only the items changeed since a lastUpdateDate, servers provide only those items, and aggs cache earlier items.
That's starting to sound like POP3. This whole argument is silly - you have a popular site, yes, people are going to be downloading stuff from you!